Genealogy Wise

The Genealogy & Family History Social Network

Even more on standardization of place names

The starting point for the use of place names in a family history or genealogical context is the rule that the place is the location at the time the event happened, especially if the place name was different at the time of the event. If there is a need for further explanation, the modern or current place name should be in a note. The reason for this rule is simple, any other notation obscures the historical reality and makes further investigation more difficult.

From the perspective of genealogy, geographic locations have several components;
A. The actual physical location on the earth which can be expressed through latitude and longitude coordinates.
B. The name of the location which can change over time, depending on historical circumstances.
C. The location of the place within any applicable political subdivision.
D. The repository of the political, social or religious records about the location.
Read more...

Views: 16

Comment

You need to be a member of Genealogy Wise to add comments!

Join Genealogy Wise

Comment by Catherine Davis on December 17, 2009 at 10:40pm
Latitudinal and longitudinal coordinates already give us a set of standardized "place names" for every spot on the earth. This idea of defining spots on the earth by coordinates is relatively modern, a 17th or 18th century concept (the actual date escapes me), but once invented, it became a constant to which all other identifiers across time can be marked. As genealogists, we can use this methodology to help us map where our ancestors lived, and give us a better understanding of their whereabouts in terms of our own modern world. As one who majored in math in college, I totally value mathematical mappings and understand their importance, even to genealogists. But I also know that a reliance only on these mathematical markers detracts from the historical "story" of our ancestors which is so vital to our better understanding of our family. We learn something about our ancestors if If we discover they chose to live in a town in this country that bore the same name as their hometown in the old country; if that town chose to change its name for some reason--to recognize a local hero, make a political point, better describe the geography of the area, or just because everyone liked a new name better--that also tells us something. The analogy is the same in Europe--whether a district in Flanders was Dixmuide or Lys gives a really big clue as to who was running the country at the time.

If computer jockeys need standardized names for a place, let them use the already defined coordinates used in road maps, Google maps, GPS, etc. This gives them the info needed to "sort" data. But let's not sanitize the world and destroy history by inventing a lot of new names for places that have colorful histories that should be preserved.

Members

© 2024   Created by IIGSExecDirector.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service